Showing posts with label the Tan War of Ireland 1920. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the Tan War of Ireland 1920. Show all posts

Tuesday, 5 September 2017

The Black and Tans by Richard Bennett

The Black and Tans

My rating: 5 of 5 stars

A very insightful view of the supplementary policemen that were sent out to Ireland to support the Royal Irish Constabulary. With mass unemployment for unskilled ex-squaddies from the Great War, it was attractive money. A generation of young men who had not been apprentices of any trade due to fighting in Europe.

The British government could take their pick of the many young veteran applicants. And they did. The most hardened and thuggish of the chosen crop, was the better in the eyes of the recruiters. This combined with drinking and a lack of respect for their R.I.C. supervision would lead to dire consequences.

There was not enough dark green (almost black) R.I.C. uniform for the reserves. So there was a mixture of kit between R.I.C. dark green and British Army service dress Khaki. Hence the nickname, Black and Tans.

This historical account gives a remarkable insight into the infamous men of the supplementary police (Black and Tans) assisting the R.I.C. against the Irish Republican rebels in the Independence struggle. It takes a look at some of the aspects of the struggle from the perspective of the rogue policemen and forms a picture of how their brand of diabolical community policing turned more and more of the indigenous population against the continued rule of Britain.

The Black and Tan Summer: Ireland's Turbulent Year of 1920



View all my reviews

Saturday, 23 August 2014

The Good, the bad and the ugly - Very Mixed Reviews for The Black and Tan Summer by C.A. Powell

The Black and Tan Summer has had some fine reviews and also attracted bad ones too. I suppose this is to be expected. One of the bad one says; the plot is simplistic and there are no bad books but fussy readers. I should take some comfort from this.

I take a step back and say to myself, "I wanted a simplistic plot." Why does it need to be complicated?

There was also another review that says the writing was poor because of the dialouge. People never spoke in such a way back in 1920. Well I guess I'll have to take that one on the chin. The book was professionally edited, but one can't please all the people all of the time.

The book is selling well around the Isles (Britain and Ireland) and in the USA. I just can't always understand why certain people want complex plots. Still, I'll keep plugging away. Reviews are reviews - good or bad - people are giving it a go.

The reviews: Check out the good the bad and the ugly! and this one.